Modia Minotaur

Trawling the airwaves to spare you the agony!

Wednesday, July 26, 2006

A Question of Consultation

Today's Law Reform Commission report floating the notion of allowing juries to participate in sentencing opens an interesting issue, and there's many ways to look at it.

The idea has, of course, gone over very well with the soft justice lobby - those who monopolise talkback airwaves following major crimes and sentences, mouthing the axiom that judges are `out of touch', and the sentences they deliver `not in keeping with community expectations'. However, as the Daily Telegraph (of all places) notes, the idea would also deprive these same callers of their ability of blaming politicians and judges for sentences they judge too lenient.

My immediate response to this comes from the mouth of Toby Ziegler of `The West Wing' : `Aw, c'mon! It's not meant to be a show of hands!'. The legacy of classical Greek democracy has left us with the romantic notion that decisions made by the public are inherently correct (though the public of Ancient Greece didn't include women or slaves). The theory of the democratic deficit suggests that this legacy is partially responsible for the mistrust of modern governments.

Perhaps to address this problem, public consultation is increasingly seen as an essential part of policymaking. No decision on where to put a highway, build a piece of infrastructure, or even introduce a new sort of chocolate bar has been done after extensive consultation. Currently, the town of Toowoomba is holding a referendum on whether it will allow recycled sewage to be fed into the water supply. Meanwhile, the NSW Government is offering a system of online (though fairly limited) consultation on its State Plan. Meanwhile, in some Scandanavian countries, citizens are summoned to participate in government policymaking as Australians are summoned to serve on juries.

Does consultation actually result in better policies? Optimistic consultation theorists suggest that the more someone knows about a topic, the more likely they are to be able to make the best decision. Pessimistic ones argue that consulation is a clever way that unsympathetic organisations can make people feel as if they are involved in decision making without having any requirement to follow their recommendations on one hand and, on the other, absolve themselves if the wrong decision is made, or gently prod proceedings in a certain direction and claim a ringing endorsement of the `right' decision by the wider public (the Republic referendum springs to mind here).

I think I'm somewhere in between these two views. I hate nothing more than someone who holds a passionate, and passionately misinformed, view. Consultation processes can engage and educate people who usually rely on others to make the hard decisions for them. Ideally, this would be what occurs on a jury. However, this is also what already happens on a jury. Giving total sway on sentencing to a body of people without the experience of countless similar, dissimilar, better and worse cases that a judge has, sounds pretty undesirable to me - and, I would imagine, the government if they think hard about it.

6 Comments:

At 11:29 am, Blogger Armagnac Esq. said...

I think it is ammoral. The jury system itself poses many quandraries, but at least is currently confined to findings of fact.

Judges are accountable far more than they are given credit for, because they have to give reasons and can be appealed against.

A perfect example of why juries shouldn't do too much of the work of judges is provided by US personal injuries cases; all the big famous ones like the mcdonalds case with ridiculous payouts come from jury decisions.

Juries are swayed heavily by good advocates, much more so than judges, meaning the quality of justice is far more affected by having a silver tongued silk. I don't see any benefit to extending this.

 
At 12:30 pm, Blogger Minotaur said...

I really don't think the idea will be adopted. Apart from anything, it's already difficult enough to convince many people that jury duty is worthwhile. Speaking for myself, I certainly wouldn't want to have the responsibility for sentencing. If I was the one in the dock, I'd certainly prefer the decision be made by someone with years of experience rather than twelve average Joes and Josephines whose experience of the law extends only to occasionally watching `Judging Amy'.

 
At 4:36 pm, Blogger oakleyses said...

longchamp outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, ugg boots clearance, michael kors outlet, prada handbags, uggs outlet, christian louboutin, louboutin shoes, louis vuitton, louis vuitton outlet, michael kors outlet, cheap uggs, chanel handbags, rolex watches, nike free, oakley sunglasses, ugg outlet, louis vuitton handbags, kate spade outlet, longchamp handbags, polo ralph lauren, ray ban sunglasses, nike shoes, longchamp handbags, tory burch outlet, oakley sunglasses, gucci outlet, tiffany and co, oakley sunglasses cheap, michael kors outlet, replica watches, prada outlet, michael kors outlet, michael kors outlet, burberry outlet, uggs, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet stores, polo ralph lauren outlet, louis vuitton outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louboutin outlet, michael kors outlet online sale, burberry outlet, louboutin, air max, tiffany and co, ray ban sunglasses

 
At 4:39 pm, Blogger oakleyses said...

abercrombie and fitch, nike free pas cher, polo ralph lauren, lululemon outlet online, kate spade handbags, nike tn, michael kors uk, coach outlet store online, hollister, air max pas cher, vans pas cher, nike air force, polo lacoste, sac hermes, hollister, louboutin, sac burberry, true religion outlet, oakley pas cher, mulberry, longchamp, ray ban sunglasses, nike blazer, coach outlet, air max, nike roshe, sac longchamp pas cher, nike air max, air jordan, coach purses, coach factory outlet, air max, north face, nike free, converse pas cher, michael kors outlet, ray ban pas cher, true religion outlet, true religion jeans, new balance pas cher, north face, michael kors, true religion jeans, sac guess, nike roshe run pas cher, ralph lauren, vanessa bruno, michael kors pas cher, timberland, hogan outlet

 
At 4:41 pm, Blogger oakleyses said...

chi flat iron, iphone cases, air max, converse, new balance shoes, nfl jerseys, ferragamo shoes, herve leger, nike roshe run, converse shoes, oakley, hollister clothing store, hollister, north face outlet, beats by dre, wedding dresses, nike huaraches, abercrombie, north face jackets, vans, celine handbags, birkin bag, babyliss pro, timberland boots, reebok outlet, abercrombie and fitch, mont blanc, instyler, ghd, jimmy choo outlet, mcm handbags, asics running shoes, soccer jerseys, giuseppe zanotti, ralph lauren, air max, soccer shoes, lululemon outlet, valentino shoes, baseball bats, vans shoes, gucci, insanity workout, louboutin, nike trainers, longchamp, ray ban, p90x, bottega veneta, mac cosmetics

 
At 4:44 pm, Blogger oakleyses said...

links of london, moncler, ugg, thomas sabo, pandora jewelry, ugg, sac louis vuitton, michael kors outlet online, moncler, moncler, hollister, moncler, montre homme, doke gabbana, louis vuitton, sac lancel, canada goose, ugg boots, moncler outlet, wedding dresses, ugg pas cher, sac louis vuitton, canada goose, coach outlet store online, ugg, michael kors handbags, louis vuitton, pandora jewelry, rolex watches, barbour, pandora charms, canada goose uk, louis vuitton uk, marc jacobs, toms shoes, canada goose, moncler, michael kors outlet, supra shoes, canada goose, moncler, barbour, canada goose outlet, swarovski crystal, juicy couture outlet, moncler, canada goose, juicy couture, karen millen, canada goose jackets, swarovski, pandora charms

 

Post a Comment

<< Home